This is the best non toxic eyeliner I've tried yet! The reviews said about the brush being too stiff and really it's not that bad..I've had other non toxic liquid liner brushes be way way worse. That said it could be a little better. My only complaint which isn't much of a complaint is that the brown Valley shade is more black then brown..I'm not even sure I would even call it black/brown bc when it dries it just looks like a faded black but it compliments my eyes(I hate extreme black eyeliners).
Rating: [4 of 5 Stars!]